Joey Dee's career started in his hometown of Passaic, New Jersey. His original group "The Thunder Trio" consisted of Joey on harmonica, John Yanick on guitar, Tony "Dutchie" Sciuto on drums. the group then morphed into Joey Dee & The Starliters. This group consisted of Joey on alto-sax,"Dutchie" on drums, Ralph Fazio on accordion, Ernie Cassini on trumpet Tony Saragusa on bass and John Yanick on guitar. The group further evovled when Vince Corrao(guitar) David McLane(guitar), Don Martin (drums), Ernie Interella (keyboard), and Rodgers Freeman (lead vocals). Joey Dee and The Starliters' first single was "Lorraine," backed with "The Girl I Walk To School," in 1958, distributed by the company Little. That same year, Joey Dee recruited David Brigati for the team after meeting him during a gig at Garfield High School in New Jersey. David and Rodgers would subsequently share lead vocal honors for The Starliters, with Joey ultimately becoming the primary lead singer. Another early single for the group was "Face of an Angel," with David as lead vocal, released on Scepter Records; the flipside was "Shimmy Baby." An album entitled The Peppermint Twisters and credited to "Joey Dee and The Starliters" was subsequently released by the company Scepter as well.
Various members of The Starliters, rotated during the next few years. The most famous lineup of Joey Dee and The Starliters, is considered to be Joey Dee, David Brigati, Larry Vernieri (vocals), Carlton Lattimore (organ). Carlton was replaced by was replaced by Bill Callanan who left their European tour, and was himself replaced by Felix Cavaliere. There was also, Sam Taylor (guitar) and Willie Davis (drums). Later members of the touring group would include Eddie Brigati (David's brother), Gene Cornish, and Felix Cavaliere - three-quarters of The Young Rascals, as well as guitarist Jimmy James (later known as Jimi Hendrix), Charles Neville of The Neville Brothers, and a young Joe Pesci on guitar.
In 1960, The Starliters were noticed by agent Don Davis while performing at a Lodi, New Jersey nightclub called Olivieri's. The group was booked at an intimate venue on 45th Street in New York City called thePeppermint Lounge for what was supposed to be a one-time weekend gig. During their initial appearance at the nightclub, actress Merle Oberon and Prince Serge Oblinski were dancing much of the night there. This being related in print the next morning by columnists Earl Wilson and Cholly Knickerbocker, it took barricades and mounted police to keep the crowds in line, which had backed to Broadway, the next night. For several months, the craze would continue at the Lounge. Celebrity visitors continued to come and included Judy Garland, Andy Warhol, John Wayne, Jackie Kennedy, Nat "King" Cole, Shirley MacLaine, Shelley Winters Tennessee Williams, Truman Capote, Salvador Dali and Liberace. Dee and company made such a sensation that they became the house band for the Peppermint Lounge, remaining for more than a year. Dee wrote "Peppermint Twist," along with producer Henry Glover, as a tribute to the lounge and the song scored #1 on the U.S. charts in early 1962. It sold over one million copies, and was awarded a gold disc by Dick Clark of American Bandstand. By this time the team had contracted with Roulette Records.
One night in 1961, a trio of pretty teenagers were waiting on line outside the nightclub hoping to be allowed inside. Dressed in matching brightly colored dresses, they looked like professional entertainers (which in fact they were) and in a case of mistaken identity, thinking they were the dancers he'd hired, the manager of the Peppermint Lounge ushered the girls – Ronnie and Estelle Bennett and their cousin, Nedra Talley – up to the stage and told them to dance. The Ronettes spent the rest of that night dancing and singing along with Joey Dee and The Starliters, and the reaction from the group and the crowd was so positive that Joey offered the girls a job. Every night, The Ronettes would dance and perform along with The Starliters at the Peppermint Lounge, even traveling with them to the nightclub'sMiami, Florida location in early 1962.
Also in early 1962, Joey Dee and The Starliters filmed the movie "Hey, Let's Twist", starring Jo Ann Campbell and Teddy Randazzo, for Paramount Pictures. Hey, Let's Twist was a fictional story of Joey Dee (Randazzo and Dino DiLuca played the parts of Joey's brother and father, respectively) and the Peppermint Lounge; its release capitalized on the current Twist craze and made the once-obscure Lounge famous. The movie and soundtrack album did their part in making the Peppermint Lounge a world-famous venue. Successful singles spawned from Hey, Let's Twist were the title track and "Shout - Part I," which became the group's second-biggest selling record, reaching #6 on the U.S. charts. It also sold a million copies, giving the group their second gold disc. Other albums released during this time were Doin' The Twist At The Peppermint Lounge, which was recorded live at the venue, and All The World's Twistin' With Joey Dee & The Starliters.
In 1962, Joey Dee and The Starliters starred in their second motion picture, Two Tickets to Paris, along with Gary Crosby, Jeri Lynne Fraser and Kay Medford. One of the songs from this film, "What Kind Of Love Is This," written by Johnny Nash, was released in September of that year and scored Top Twenty. In December 1962, the original Starliters did their final recording session as a group, producing "Help Me Pick Up the Pieces," also composed by Nash, and "Baby, You're Driving Me Crazy," written by Joey Dee and Henry Glover. In 1963, Joey Dee recorded an album entitled Dance, Dance, Dance, with The Ronettes as his backup group. During spring of that year, Roulette released the track "Hot Pastrami with Mashed Potatoes," from the previously issued live album, as a two-part single; the record made the U.S. Top Forty. Roulette later released "Ya Ya" and "Fannie Mae" from the same album. During October and November 1963, The Starliters toured Europe, performing one extraordinary night in Stockholm with The Beatles (already the biggest band in Northern Europe) as their opening act. In 1964, Joey Dee toured with various Starliters including Cornish, Cavaliere, and Eddie Brigati. Other group members at different times included Jimi Hendrix, who toured with the group in late 1965, Charles Neville (later of the Neville Brothers) and – early in their history – Joe Pesci played guitar with the band.